Silicon Valley loves The Sovereign Individual but never quotes its last chapter. The rest of us should read it too.

In October, a company filing revealed that Mark Zuckerberg had told Meta’s board that he was considering leaving California. The reason was Proposition 40, a ballot measure that would have levied a one-time 5 per cent tax on the wealth of the state’s billionaires. His bill was estimated to be about $12 billion. To pay it he would have had to sell shares, and along with those some of the voting power that gives him control of the company.
The board duly produced a workaround. It created a new class of non-voting stock that Zuckerberg could sell instead, and he pledged to remain a California resident for eight years. Some shareholders have sued. Then, on November 3, voters made the question moot – at least for now – by rejecting the tax, 52.8 per cent to 47.2.
I’ll come back to whether that tax was a good idea. What interests me first is the shape of this episode. The tax would apply to anyone living in California on January 1, 2026. Before that date – ten months before the vote – Google founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin had left the state and bought property in Florida (Brin went on to spend more than $100 million campaigning against the tax), and Peter Thiel’s investment firm had opened an office in Miami. So, a state proposes to tax its richest residents, and some of them left before the question was even put. That sequence was described, almost step by step, in a book published in 1997.
The Sovereign Individual, by the American investor James Dale Davidson and William Rees-Mogg, a former editor of The Times in London, argued that the internet would free the wealthy from the nation-state. Money and work would move online, beyond government reach. People with means would shop around among jurisdictions, which would have to compete for them “just as hotels and restaurants do”. They would settle their taxes “by private treaty”.
The authors had a particular grievance in mind when they wrote their book: a Clinton-era proposal to tax Americans who gave up their citizenship, which they called a “Berlin Wall for Capital”. Leaving, they wrote, beats arguing: “Voting with your feet and your money has the great advantage that it leads to results that you desire.”
The book is scripture for part of Silicon Valley. Peter Thiel wrote the preface to the 2020 edition. Its critics, and I am one, tend to treat the book as a bit of a crank’s prophecy. But that undersells it if I’m fair. The book foresaw digital money secured by encryption. It foresaw work broken into tasks and done by contractors, much like today’s gig economy. It foresaw a nationalist reaction against globalisation and immigration, complete with “popular hatred of the information elite”. And it foresaw that a tax on great wealth would be met with credible threats to go.
The book got some big things wrong as well. The nation-state has not dissolved. Canada and Italy, which the authors expected would “almost surely disintegrate” before now, are still there. Politics has not died. Even Zuckerberg, in the end, settled to stay. But on its central mechanism, the idea of exit, the book was right, and those of us who dislike its conclusions should say so.
What I did not expect, when I read the book this summer, was how it ends. After hundreds of pages welcoming the Sovereign Individual, the last chapter changes tone and asks what sort of person he will be (always he; it was the ‘90s). The answer is pretty bleak.
The new elite, the authors write, will have had “little religious or moral education in the family.” Its households are “split by divorce, remarriage, and subsequent third marriages.” Its children will be taught “the lessons of economic efficiency, the use of resources, the pursuit of money, but not the virtues of humility or self-sacrifice.” By the standards of the great moral teachers, “they may be moral illiterates”. There’s a sentence the book’s admirers don’t quote: “A godless, rootless, and rich elite is unlikely to be happy, or to be loved.”
Some of this is a period piece. The lament for chastity and the nostalgia for the piety of “an Irish or Polish village” belong to a particular religious sensibility, and I don’t think divorce or unbelief makes anyone a worse citizen. But take the theology away and what’s left, in the authors’ own words, is this: “Societies, as we have argued, can only be strong if real moral values are widely shared.” They described the alienation between a superclass and everyone else as “extremely dangerous”.
That’s a remarkable thing to find at the end of this book. The authors have spent the whole of it explaining that a country is a service provider and a citizen is a customer. Then, finally, they note that nobody loves a customer and that a customer loves nothing. Davidson and Rees-Mogg never resolve the contradiction and their admirers run with the forecast but leave the warning about morality. I think the last chapter is right, and that the rest of the book should be judged by it.
The freedom to leave is a real liberty. The authors are right that a state that has to wall its people in has already lost the argument. But having the right to leave is one thing, and using it as a lever is another. The first is freedom. The second treats the place where you have lived, built, and prospered as a supplier with its terms up for renegotiation. It is legal. It is also, by the book’s own account, how someone behaves who was raised on efficiency and not on obligation.
The economist Albert Hirschman, whom the authors cite, called his best-known book Exit, Voice, and Loyalty. Davidson and Rees-Mogg embraced the first, dismissed the second, and spent their final chapter concerned about the third. Loyalty for Hirschman is what makes a person stay and argue when leaving would be easier, it’s what gives a wobbling institution time to right itself. Loyalty cannot be bought because that turns it into a contract. Zuckerberg’s case is a little less clear-cut because he told his board he might leave and the deal that followed was designed to let him pay rather than escape. That the other party was his own board rather than the state doesn’t make it less of a contract, though.
Many liberals today have grown shy of this language. Loyalty sounds like something that nationalists demand. There is another, less flattering reason too. We built institutions to look after the common good and then stopped treating it as our own business: pay what the law requires, and the rest is someone else’s job. The authors predicted – accurately – that nationalists would be the ones to demand loyalty, on behalf of the people the book calls the “losers and left-behinds”. That is the price of the silence. If those who believe in open societies will not say that the people who gain most from them owe more too, others will say it for them, in worse terms, and add a wall.
Loyalty runs in both directions, though. I am not persuaded that the state should lean heavily on a handful of very rich residents to keep everyone else comfortable. That’s the same as expecting someone else to take care of the common good, and it treats those residents as a resource in the same way they are accused of treating the state. If excessive fortunes are the problem, then the time to question how they are made is while they are being made, and not afterwards, not when those fortunes have been visibly piling up for the last 40-odd years.
None of that excuses just leaving or threatening to do so. We don’t need laws to say that a billionaire who responds to a ballot measure by moving to Florida has behaved selfishly, or to think better of those who stay, make their case in public, and live with the result.
But I’d be letting myself off lightly if I stopped there. Most of us will never be able to leave the way Page or Brin did. Still, many liberals have our own version of exit: pay what we owe, and leave the common good to the state, the charities and whoever turns up willing to put in the effort. Loyalty, in Hirschman’s sense, means staying and arguing, and that asks something of everyone who stays. A country is not a hotel. That goes for the guest who threatens to check out, for the management that sees him as little more than a bill in the making, and for the rest of us, who settle our bills and leave everything else to the staff.

Leave a Reply